LINKS:- Front Page | Introduction | Biosketch | Our Services | Articles | Email Message Form | Ask a Question | Contact/Links

Copyright © LK 2002 © LK 2003 All rights reserved

Articles:
* Car Park Design - the Devil is in the Detail
* Car Park Engineering Design: Working Together for 'Win-Win' Solutions
* Turning Circles at Public Car Park Exits
* Car Park Design - An Irish Perspective
* The Vertical Challenge in Car Parks
* The Economics of Pay Car Parks
* Car Parking in Towns - A Very Big Challenge Today!
* The Economic Boom in Ireland: Parking Implications
* The Value of a Parking Space
* Cheaper parking on the way?
* Hospital Parking: Cars, Cranes and Confusion
* The Great Shopping Centre Car Park Space Hunt
* Ramps in Car Parks

Introduction:

Car park design teams face many trade offs, including a challenge between maximising the number of spaces in the new facility, and ensuring that it functions smoothly for drivers and their cars. To optimise capacity in a given spatial “cube” requires the maximum number of levels and consequently the minimising of floor to ceiling heights. Today the recommended clearance in a multi-storey car park is 2.1m.

This approach sometimes to leads to people forgetting that cars are three-dimensional objects with height, length and width, and that, in addition, they are moving within the structure.

Absolute Height

All cars must be capable of getting through the entry under the height restrictor. In a single deck car park there are no significant height issues other than absolute height of the car. When ramps are involved a whole new range of issues arise.

On the basis that less than 1% of all private cars have engine capacities of more than 2.5 litres, it may follow that the height issue is small one.

Length/Height

As cars move from the level up or down a ramp, the combination of length and height is key to whether the roof of the car hits the concrete ceiling or cross beams, or whether the bottom of the car scrapes floor at the top of the ramp.

Load Factor

A car that enters a car park with a heavy load, down on its axles, and attempts to leave unladen, is likely to collide with a cross beam. A flatbed truck entering with a long ladder laid flat, but later repositioned so that it sticks out or up, may face the same problem.

Aerials

Cars with telescoping aerials can pose a problem – going in the aerial is down and nobody notices a problem. As the car leaves the driver switches on the radio and up goes the aerial to intercept the beams and trusses. Whip aerials get under the entry barriers and batter the light boxes and signs.

Roof-racks

Many drivers forget that when they put a roof rack on their car that the height of the vehicle is increased. We have had all the lights in the car park entrance ripped out by drivers rushing to the shops before they leave on holidays. Bicycles stacked on a car roof pose the same problem.

Tailgates

Cars and 4x4s with tailgates that open up at the rear pose a problem because drivers forget that there is a ceiling above them! We have all had arguments with drivers who claimed that it was our fault that their tailgate was damaged when they had opened it and let it fly up into the ceiling!

Ramps/Low Spots

Most car parks have areas, e.g. under ramps, where cars can park provided the driver is cautious. Some spaces are perfect for cars that drive in but totally unsuitable for cars that reverse in. These spaces need clear warnings/signs for cars and people.

Driver Height

We sometimes forget that drivers can be very tall and that, even when a car can fit comfortably into a car park, a tall driver getting out is likely to hit his head against a low ceiling or a cross beam. This is also an issue where structural walls/beams protrude into pedestrian walkways.

Surface Car Parks

Vehicle heights are an issue in surface car parks also. Tall vehicles can block the lines of sight for car park staff, and can offer vandals an opportunity to interfere with cars hidden from sight. We have banned panel trucks from several sites. If a surface site caters for tall vehicles – HGVs, buses etc., where drivers are positioned high above the road - there are issues of access, e.g. to get tickets, or to pay without getting out of the cab. Bewley's Hotel at Newland’s Cross has a neat solution – an intercom mounted on a 10 ft high pole at both the ‘in’ and the ‘out’ barriers.

What to Do

The current practice is to place signs at the car park entrance stating the maximum height of vehicle permitted to enter. Many car parks also erect a restrictor at the car park entrance, which is set at the maximum permitted height. This can also be enhanced by a swinging board, which allows for contact between the car roof and the board with little fear of damage. This however does not address the issues posed by ramps, where the effective height is limited by the length of the vehicle. We recommend that a long high car be carefully driven through the car park and all height hazards identified and signposted.

Conclusion

99% of cars using public car parks do not have any height problems, provided the car park has indicated that there is a height limit, helped the driver assess the clearance under the height barrier and considered the height issues for long high cars at ramps. The onus must be on the driver to accept responsibility for their vehicles and to drive carefully within the car park.






Liam Keilthy
CEO of Park Rite Limited 1994-2001.
Phone: 1-353-1-2893746 Email: Liam Keilthy

Copyright © LK 2002 All rights reserved
This article is reproduced here with the permission of the author. Copyright remains at all times with the author, and the opinions expressed are his alone.

Print this page